All-Inclusive Stays vs Cruises: Which One is Right For You? (Including Australian Options)

MEGAN HARRIS • March 26, 2026

You may be an all-aboard enthusiast who struggles to believe that a land-based stay could rival a cruise for experience or value but  I'm noticing more and more clients are starting to ask whether an all-inclusive resort might offer a more relaxed, flexible and refined alternative.


Both options promise an easy, largely pre-planned holiday… but the experience can feel quite different.


My recent visit to Mt Mulligan Lodge has provided me with some perspective on the similarities and differences between an all-inclusive land lodge stay versus a floating resort in the form of a cruise.


So how do you decide whether an all-inclusive stay is right for you?

What is an all-inclusive stay?

Mt Mulligan Lodge offers all-inclusive stays

An all-inclusive stay typically means your key travel costs are bundled into one upfront price.


Depending on the lodge or resort, this can include:

  • Accommodation
  • Meals and snacks
  • Drinks (including alcohol at most)
  • Onsite activities and entertainment
  • Sometimes even airport transfers

The idea is simple — once you arrive, everything is taken care of.


I find that many clients associate all-inclusive stays with overseas resorts, but Australia offers its own elevated lodges.


Most clients are surprised when I break down the per-day cost of an Australian luxury lodge stay—including accommodation, meals, drinks, and activities—and are surprised at how it stacks up against a quality cruise. And with the added space, comfort, and personalised service, the value of an all-inclusive lodge stay is hard to beat.

All inclusive stay vs cruise: how they compare

Rooms with a View

El Questro rooms have amazing views

Just like on a cruise, an all-inclusive lodge offers the joy of unpacking once and having everything you need within easy reach, but unlike a cruise, there's no need to pay for a balcony upgrade!


All Luxury Lodges of Australia have spacious, beautifully designed guest rooms that are situated to make the most of the stunning views of the surrounding landscape.


Rooms are well-equipped and often feature amenities like outdoor bath tubs and boutique complimentary bathroom products highlighting Australian ingredients.


All inclusive stays are offered on small-scale properties, providing space and privacy for all guests. 

Want to find an all-inclusive stay that's right for you? I offer a complimentary consultation that's designed to match you to the perfect experience.

Gourmet Dining

Forget buffet lines! At an all-inclusive lodge, your meals are carefully curated and plated by top-tier chefs, using fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Whether it’s a leisurely breakfast, a long lunch, or a gourmet dinner under the stars, each meal is an experience in itself—no upcharges, no hidden fees, and no need to book a specialty restaurant in advance.

Premium Inclusions—No Surprises

There’s no need to upgrade your drinks package, pay for Wi-Fi, or navigate a maze of add-ons that quickly inflate your total cost.  At Mt Mulligan Lodge, high-quality beverages, including premium wines and spirits, are part of the package, as is seamless high-speed internet—so you can disconnect or stay connected as you please.

Fewer Guests, More Space

Most all-inclusive lodges cater to fewer than 50 guests at a time. This means personalised service, quiet surroundings, and a true sense of exclusivity. No crowded pools, no queues at the bar, no fighting for a lounge chair. Just pure relaxation in a natural setting.

Activities That Immerse You in Your Destination

Onshore cruise excursions often follow the well-worn tourist trail—quick stops at the most popular sights, large group tours, and experiences that, while enjoyable, can feel a little ‘one-size-fits-all.’


In contrast, at a luxury lodge, activities are carefully curated to immerse you in the unique history, culture and environment of the region. Whether it’s a guided expedition with an expert to appreciate the Indigenous heritage of the land, a hands-on experience with local produce, or a wilderness adventure designed specifically for the season, every activity is crafted to be meaningful, intimate, and truly special.

Saffire Freycinet has gourmet dining and premium inclusions

All-Inclusive Stays vs Cruises: At a Glance

At a glance, cruises and all-inclusive stays can seem quite similar. But the feel of the holiday is where the difference really comes through.

All-Inclusive Stay

Cruise

One destination, explored in depth

Settle in once; no packing/unpacking

Flexible pace; do as much or as little as you like

Space, privacy, and a more boutique feel

Immersive, location-based experiences

Food and wine often locally sourced and regionally inspired

Ideal for switching off and slowing down

Feels more like a retreat

Multiple destinations in one trip

Frequent packing/unpacking between ports

Structured schedules and set dining times

Shared spaces with larger numbers of guests

Snapshot-style visits to destinations

Dining designed to cater to a wide range of tastes

Ideal for variety and constant activity

Feels more like a journey


Have I Convinced You?

While cruising is still incredibly popular, all-inclusive stays — particularly in Australia — are becoming a go-to for travellers who want:


  • A slower pace. No schedules to follow unless you want them
  • Less decision fatigue. Everything is thoughtfully curated
  • A deeper connection to place; not just passing through
  • A true sense of switching off; without sacrificing quality or experience


If your version of a holiday involves arriving, exhaling, and knowing everything has already been taken care of, an all-inclusive stay can be a very good fit.


I regularly work with clients who are weighing up different styles of travel and help them land on the option that truly gives them their version of “me time.”  Book a complimentary consult today to find an all-inclusive lodge that's right for you.

Use a travel agent to book your flights

Think Booking Flights Is Just Clicking a Button?

By MEGAN HARRIS • June 20, 2025
Why you should use a travel agent to book your flights. Travel agents research flight options and provide reservation management after booking.
use a personal travel agent to travel to participate in fitness events

Travel + Participation in Sporting Events: Why It's A Winning Combination

By MEGAN HARRIS • March 11, 2025
If your next holiday involves lacing up your running shoes, clipping into your bike pedals, or diving into open water to participate in sporting challenges, you are amongst a growing trend. Travelling to participate in an event helps you feel a sense of community, explore new destinations, and maintain motivation.
It's take more than just physical relaxation to recover from the demands of work

Plan your holiday to rocket to recovery

By MEGAN HARRIS • January 15, 2025
5 ways to ensure your holiday helps you truly recover from the demands of work